Greater Hartford Plumber Director
Menu

Nutmeg Roofing Company

Updated 2026-09-21 · 1,346 reviewed · 139 listed · Scored from 69 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.7(69) 77 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Roofing ContractorRoof RepairResidential RoofingCommercial RoofingMetal RoofingRoof Inspection & GuttersRoof Replacement & Installation
Nutmeg Roofing Company
Location
Orange
Services
Roofing Contractor, Roof Repair, Residential Roofing
Reviews
69
Ranking
#22 in Roofing Contractor
Best for
Homeowners needing fast emergency roof repair or replacements, and those managing insurance claims.

Business data from Google Business Profile, checked 2026-09-21.

What recent reviews say

Most reviewers praise Nutmeg for rapid response, with owner Sonny often answering calls directly and handling emergency repairs same-day, even weekends. Work quality and crew professionalism earn consistent five-star marks for roof replacement, repairs, and gutter jobs across residential and commercial properties.

Two serious complaints stand out: one customer paid $26,000 for a pergola roof rebuild that was installed flat with no water pitch, causing hundreds of pounds of standing water and structural damage after 18 months; a second reported a missed appointment window and alleged dishonesty about traffic delays. The company disputed the flat-roof complaint via email.

Praised for
  • fast response and emergency availability
  • skilled workmanship and attention to detail
  • responsive communication and owner accessibility
  • thorough cleanup and site care
Watch-outs
  • faulty flat roof construction causing water pooling
  • failure to honor insurance claims process
  • missed appointment windows and dishonesty about delays
punctualresponsive-communicationskilled-workmanshipclean-jobsitestorm-response-speedinsurance-savvymissed-deadlinespoor-communication
Best for: Homeowners needing fast emergency roof repair or replacements, and those managing insurance claims.
Think twice if: Anyone planning a complex, non-standard roof design should verify pitch and drainage specifications in writing; one customer reported a $26,000 pergola rebuild installed flat, causing water pooling and structural failure.

Where this business shines

  • owner answers calls directly and mobilizes for same-day emergencies
  • handles insurance coordination and claims
  • crews finish jobs in one or two days
  • polite, thorough cleanup and yard care

Worth knowing

  • Sonny Mitchell, owner, takes emergency calls on weekends
  • Chris handled full roof replacement with solar panel coordination and insurance adjuster liaison
  • Team completed full roof replacement in one to one-and-a-half days
  • Offered complimentary gutter cleaning on one job
  • Also repairs slate roofs and offers driveway repair
  • Company disputes one $26,000 flat-roof complaint but ignored certified letter demanding insurance documentation

What reviews say by service

Roof Repair
Fast, often completed in rain or same-day for emergencies; chimney flashing and leak repairs praised
Roof Replacement & Installation
Completed one to two days; full replacements praised for quality finish and cleanup; one pergola roof dispute over flat construction and drainage
Residential Roofing
Strong reputation for handling ice dams, storm damage, and standard shingle replacement with crew professionalism
Roof Inspection & Gutters
Gutter replacement and cleaning completed at reasonable prices; inspections thorough and included in estimate process
Metal Roofing
No explicit metal roofing review text, though business category includes it

How it compares

  • Rated 4.7 against a 4.66 average across the 107 roofing contractor businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 91% of the businesses in this directory.

What earned this score?

How We Rank
Star rating 79
Review volume 80
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 51
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
64
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
5

Contact

Address
554 Boston Post Rd #163, Orange, CT 06477

Last verified 2026-09-21

Opening hours

Monday
00:00-24:00
Tuesday
00:00-24:00
Wednesday
00:00-24:00
Thursday
00:00-24:00
Friday
00:00-24:00
Saturday
00:00-24:00
Sunday
00:00-24:00

As listed on Google.

Enquire about Nutmeg Roofing Company

Your enquiry goes to the Greater Hartford Plumber Director team, who will pass it to Nutmeg Roofing Company. We only share your details with providers relevant to your request.

Common questions

Can Nutmeg respond to a roof leak on a weekend or in an emergency?
Yes. Owner Sonny has handled same-day emergency repairs on Saturdays, even working into the night during blizzards.
Do they work with insurance companies?
Yes. Chris coordinates with insurance adjusters and claims; one customer cited insurance company coordination during replacement.
How long does a roof replacement take?
Typically one to one-and-a-half days from start to finish, including cleanup.

Similar roofing contractor nearby

Ace Roofing | Commercial | Industrial | Residential
81

Ace Roofing | Commercial | Industrial | Residential

5.0(14)✓ Google-verified

All 14 reviews give five stars. Reviewers consistently praise Jonathan and his team for showing up fast, finishing on time, and charging fairly. Work quality is noted across emergency repairs, full roof replacements, and inspections. One reviewer highlighted how Ace takes small repair jobs seriously, unlike competitors who push only for replacements.

Roof RepairCommercial RoofingMetal Roofing
Rens Do It All LLC
62 low data

Rens Do It All LLC

5.0(12)✓ Google-verified

Rens Do It All maintains a perfect five-star rating on 12 reviews. Customers note the team's patience, hard work, and readiness to exceed expectations on repairs and replacements.

Roof RepairRoof Replacement & InstallationRoofing Contractor
Professional Roofers LLC
69 low data

Professional Roofers LLC

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Both five-star reviewers praised storm damage inspections that caught issues they'd missed, smooth insurance coordination, and transparent communication. One noted pricing nearly half that of competitors, with windows and roof work completed to their satisfaction.

Roofing ContractorRoof RepairRoof Replacement & Installation

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-09-21