Can you handle roof work in bad weather?

Yes. Reviews mention repairs completed in rain and workers staying late into the night during a blizzard.

Do you help with insurance claims?

Yes. Recent full-roof customer reported Chris coordinated directly with the insurance adjuster and explained the entire claims process.

How quickly can you respond to an emergency?

On a Saturday with an ice dam, crew arrived same day and worked into the night. On weekdays, estimate provided in under 15 minutes.

Nutmeg Roofing Company

Updated 2026-07-21 · 881 reviewed · 100 listed · Scored from 68 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.8(68) 84 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified

Residential RoofingCommercial RoofingRoof RepairRoof Replacement & InstallationRoofing Contractor

Google-verified68 Google reviews

Services: Residential Roofing, Commercial Roofing, Roof Repair
Reviews: 68

What recent reviews say

Nutmeg Roofing delivers quick turnarounds and honest estimates on emergency repairs and full replacements. Sonny and his crew earn consistent praise for picking up the phone fast, explaining the entire process (including insurance coordination), and finishing jobs in a day or two with meticulous cleanup.

The standout detail is their willingness to work nights and weekends, even during storms and ice dams. One customer reported a significant delay and misleading communication about traffic, which the business later admitted to in texts. That event remains an outlier against 68 reviews, but it flags a real gap between promise and execution on scheduling.

Praised for

responsive and fast
skilled workmanship
clear communication and transparency
professional cleanup
insurance coordination

Watch-outs

long wait times despite appointment slot
dishonesty about traffic delays

punctualskilled-workmanshipresponsive-communicationclean-jobsiteinsurance-savvyfair-pricingstorm-response-speed

Best for: Homeowners needing emergency roof repairs or full replacements under insurance pressure.

Think twice if: Schedule carefully; one customer was kept waiting 2 hours with repeated false estimates despite an appointment time.

Strengths

Same-day and weekend emergency response
Direct owner/foreman involvement (Sonny/Chris named)
Insurance claim coordination and fast estimates
Detail-oriented site cleanup

Worth knowing

Sonny (appears to be owner/foreman) picks up phone on first call
Chris handled recent full roof installation including solar panel coordination
Same-day and Saturday emergency response documented (ice dam repair)
Partial and full roof replacements completed in 1-3 days
Gutter work and snow/ice removal offered as add-ons
One documented scheduling failure: 2-hour wait with dishonest traffic excuse

What reviews say by service

Roof Repair: Fast emergency response even nights and weekends; leak diagnosis and chimney flashing repaired in hours
Roof Replacement & Installation: Full replacements completed in 1-3 days with insurance coordination and solar panel planning
Residential Roofing: Slate roof and asphalt repairs praised for speed and finish; crew cleans meticulously
Roof Inspection & Gutters: Gutter replacement and cleaning offered; one customer noted gutter cleaning as courtesy
Commercial Roofing: No detailed commercial reviews; one mention of work on a 2-family home

How it compares

Rated 4.8 against a 4.84 average across the 28 residential roofing businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 90% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

How We Rank

Star rating 84

Review volume 80

Review recency 100

Review sentiment 70

Profile completeness 100

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

Common questions

Can you handle roof work in bad weather?: Yes. Reviews mention repairs completed in rain and workers staying late into the night during a blizzard.
Do you help with insurance claims?: Yes. Recent full-roof customer reported Chris coordinated directly with the insurance adjuster and explained the entire claims process.
How quickly can you respond to an emergency?: On a Saturday with an ice dam, crew arrived same day and worked into the night. On weekdays, estimate provided in under 15 minutes.

Request a quote

Similar roofing contractor nearby

Ace Roofing | Commercial | Industrial | Residential

5.0(8)✓ Google-verified

Seven straight five-star reviews praise Jonathan's crew for same-day response, honest quotes, and fair pricing on both repairs and replacements. Work is completed as promised, with free inspections and strong attention to detail-a standout for handling small repair jobs with the same professionalism as larger projects.

Commercial RoofingResidential RoofingRoofing Contractor

View profile

60 low data

Dowl's Home Improvement Contractors, LLC

4.0(4)✓ Google-verified

Strong recent work quality and professionalism when jobs proceed, but reliability concerns persist from past reviews about poor communication and no-shows.

Commercial RoofingRoofing Contractor

View profile